3701 Kirby Drive, Suite 101
Houston, TX 77098
Contact Us

The Gibson Law Firm

KHOU 11 News

Astros fan sues for $1 million claiming Orbit’s t-shirt cannon broke her finger


HOUSTON — A Montgomery County woman is suing the Houston Astros for more than $1 million after she broke her finger at a game in July 2018, according to court documents filed Monday.

Jennifer Harughty alleges her finger was shattered when the team’s mascot, Orbit, fired a T-shirt into the stands.

The lawsuit says Harughty was at the game with her sons, husband and her father seated behind third base about halfway up the first deck when the incident occurred.


"The kids were excited again, and he shot the T-shirt, and it was coming right at me. I was like, 'Oh, my gosh! I’m finally getting the T-shirt," Harughty said.


Orbit is accused of using a “bazooka style T-shirt cannon” to rapidly fire multiple shirts into the crowd during the game's seventh inning.

“Orbit took aim and fired a T-shirt into the stands where Harughty and her family sat. The T-shirt struck her left index finger head-on and with so much force Harughty’s finger fractured,” the lawsuit stated.

The woman went to the emergency room after the game where she was told she would need surgery. She later underwent two operations to fix the fracture.

"So whenever it hit here, the pressure and the force of the T-shirt, this knuckle couldn’t withstand so it just shattered once it hit," Harughty said. "Come to find out, it was shattered. We were thinking, oh, OK, it’s broke but no big deal. It’s a finger. We’ll put a cast on it. Four weeks, you’ll be fine."

The lawsuit alleges the team was negligent in several ways, including failing to use reasonable care when firing the cannon and failure to warn fans of the risks associated with the cannon. The lawsuit also claims Astros staff were not properly trained for the safe use of the cannon.

Documents show Harughty is asking for more than $1 million for physical pain, suffering and impairment along with mental anguish and loss of any earnings both in the past and in the future.

The plaintiff is demanding the case go to a trial by jury.

The Astros released a statement Tuesday afternoon saying they "do not agree with the allegations."

"The Astros are aware of the lawsuit with allegations regarding Orbit’s t-shirt launcher. We do not agree with the allegations.The Astros will continue to use fan popular t-shirt launchers during games."

"As this is an ongoing legal matter, we will have no further comment on this matter."

The lawsuit is not the first of its kind. CBS Chicago reports that in 2013 a woman sued an Illinois town after she was struck in the face by a flying t-shirt during a festival.  In 2009 a man sued the White Sox after he was injured when fans jostled for a shirt that was launched into the stands.

View Article

The Gibson Law Firm
There was an error submitting the form, please try again.
Attorneys, clients and potential clients can ask questions or send us information about a case by filling out the form below. There is no charge for contacting us with your inquiry. An attorney will review your submission and reply back to you.
Your information was successfully submitted and we will respond shortly. If you have more information to provide or would like assistance, please contact us directly at 713-650-1010 or
All Fields Required
Processing Please Wait
Processing Please Wait...
By providing us your phone number, you are giving us permission to call you in response to this request, even if this phone number is on the State and or National "Do Not Call Registry".